links: http://newsinfo.inquirer.net/642022/palace-stands-by-purisima-says-response-to-wealth-issue-truthful
Palace backs PNP chief: He has moral ascendancy
Presidential spokesman Edwin Lacierda: In defense of Alan Purisima (inset)
MANILA, Philippines–Malacañang on Wednesday came to Director General Alan Purisima’s defense, describing his Senate testimony as “truthful” and saying he still had the “moral ascendancy” over the Philippine National Police despite allegations of corruption.
But Sen. Francis Escudero said there may be more reason to hold Purisima accountable for the big discount he got for the purchase of a sport utility vehicle last year than for the donation from his friends for the renovation of his official residence in Camp Crame.
Consumer and anticrime groups have filed plunder and indirect bribery complaints against Purisima in the Office of the Ombudsman over the renovation of his official residence, dubbed “White House,” and his Nueva Ecija property.
Presidential spokesman Edwin Lacierda said it was up to Purisima to take a leave of absence amid the charges filed against the PNP chief.
Asked if Purisima still had the moral ascendancy over his men, Lacierda replied: “Yes, I believe so.”
Even before Purisima appeared in the hearing called by the Senate committee on public order headed by Sen. Grace Poe, there have been calls from various parties for him to take a leave of absence or to resign if he could not explain the allegations against him.
But Escudero said resignation, early retirement and a leave of absence were all voluntary actions, and Purisima could not be forced to do these.
Unless the President decides to replace Purisima, he could not be forced to leave, he added.
He also said the complaints against Purisima should just continue to go through the process.
Escudero also said it would be up to Purisima and to President Aquino to decide if Purisima’s continued stay at the top PNP post was detrimental to the organization.
The PNP chief has attributed the allegations against him to syndicates affected by his efforts to clean up the corruption in the PNP Firearms and Explosives Division, and to put order to the system for the issuance of gun licenses.
Not quitting
Purisima also said he would not leave his post and would continue doing his duty.
But senators are dissatisfied with Purisima’s explanations about the process he followed for accepting the P11-million donation for the renovation of his official residence.
Poe noted at the hearing that the deed of donation was signed only on Sept. 3, 2014, when the work on the house was completed last year.
Purisima also said his friends had thought of donating the house because the PNP chief’s official residence was prone to being submerged in floods.
The donors have no contracts with the PNP, according to Purisima. He said he was just the incidental beneficiary of the donation and would be leaving the house to his successor.
Lacierda did not say whether Purisima’s answers during the Senate inquiry on Tuesday should put to rest the controversies hounding him.
“My point is he appeared before the Senate. He answered those questions truthfully and whether one [believes him or not], it depends on how one assesses his testimony and we’ll leave it to those who listened to the Senate investigation,” he said.
Conflict of interest
At the hearing, Purisima claimed he had acquired at a “discounted” price of P1.5 million a sport utility vehicle, which Poe said could be worth P4 million.
He also admitted to receiving an P11-million donation for the renovation of his official residence last year.
Purisima also came under fire over his 4.7-hectare property in Nueva Ecija, which was purportedly acquired using his salary and family savings.
Teresita Ang-See, head of the crime watchdog Movement for the Restoration of Peace and Democracy, said accepting such lucrative offers meant that Purisima’s position was untenable.
“The danger there is conflict of interest. People can capitalize on that and ask for favors, maybe not now but in the future,” she said.
Big-hearted friends
A minority bloc lawmaker said Purisima should not be blamed for having big-hearted friends.
“We can’t do anything if he has plenty of friends. It’s not illegal to have many generous friends,” Isabela Rep. Rodolfo Albano said in a text message.
He said Purisima based his testimony on the statement of assets, liabilities and net worth (SALN) where he listed his Nueva Ecija property at a low price.
Albano said the asset was probably based on its fair market value, which was also used as a basis in the payment of property taxes.
“The guy is trusted by President Aquino. Let’s give him a break. We also have to give him the benefit of doubt. He took an oath to tell the truth and nothing but the truth so help him God,” Albano said in a text message.
Eastern Samar Rep. Ben Evardone said that Purisima’s presence at the hearing showed his readiness to face the charges against him head-on.
“There are already cases filed against him and I think the court will be a good forum for him to fully explain all questions raised against him,” Evardone said.
More questions, doubts
But a member of the Liberal Party, Iloilo Rep. Niel Tupas Jr., said that Purisima raised more questions and doubts.
“He has not explained his SALN satisfactorily, he has not been straightforward in his answers. The controversy has affected the reputation of and has eroded further the people’s trust in the PNP,” Tupas said in a text message.
In the Senate, Escudero said Purisima had so far not explained the discount he enjoyed for his Toyota Land Cruiser Prado, which he bought from a San Fernando, Pampanga, car dealer for P1.5 million.
In the case of the donation for the PNP chief’s official residence, this passed through the Commission on Audit (COA) and would officially belong to the PNP, Escudero noted.
Reason for big discount
“If ever, that (Toyota Prado discount) is more likely to fall under graft instead of the donation. The donation passed through the COA and the government received it. It was for the government, and the only angle being looked at is if there would be a favor in exchange for this,” Escudero told reporters.
“But in the car issue, the angle there is why was he given a discount? Why was the discount that big and what was the reason it was given to him if it was not given to everybody who buys a car?” he added.
Poe, chair of the Senate committee on public order, noted during Tuesday’s committee hearing that a Land Cruiser Prado would have cost about P4 million, and said Purisima should have wondered why he was getting a discount.
“I’m not saying it’s your fault that you were able to get it at a discounted price. But you should have taken a second look at that big a discount…. Ask yourself, why is this being given to me at a cheaper price?” Poe said, and asked whether the dealer had a contract with the PNP.
The Toyota Philippines website put the price range of different Prado models from P2.97 million to P3.85 million each.
Purisima said the dealer had no contract with the PNP.
Lacierda did not say whether the Palace was buying Purisima’s explanations.
“I have not spoken to the President about it, but again, this is an issue where you see General Purisima answering all the questions with candor,” he said, noting that the responses were based on Purisima’s SALN.
Number of reforms cited
“We have to hand it to General Purisima that he answered all those questions truthfully.”
Asked if Purisima was still fit to lead the PNP, Lacierda cited the “number of reforms” the PNP chief had implemented, such as the “continuing improvement on the system of reporting all these incidents of crime.”
Lacierda also highlighted the “discipline that he brings to the PNP.”–With a report from AFP
-----------------------------
Purisima slams Failon, De Castro, Davila, other ABS-CBN personalities for ‘rabid’ attacks
PNP Chief Allan Purisima
MANILA, Philippines—”Tenacious” and “rabid” were how Philippine National Police (PNP) Director General Alan Purisima described Thursday the attacks of his media critics.
The embattled PNP chief said the “personal attacks” on him by Ted Failon, Noli de Castro, Karen Davila and other broadcast journalists from ABS-CBN network influenced the opinion of Senate members, who grilled him about his alleged unexplained wealth.
“Tenacious. Rabid. These are just a couple of words to describe the attacks certain quarters have launched against me,” Purisima said in a press briefing before leaving for Malacañang to attend a meeting.
He blasted the media personalities for their alleged scathing criticisms against him in their television and radio programs in relation to his supposed hidden mansion in San Leonardo, Nueva Ecija.
News anchor Failon got a special mention from Purisima in his speech, citing his show “Failon Ngayon” which showed the 4.7 hectare property of the PNP chief in the province he allegedly misdeclared in the statement of assets, liabilities and net worth (SALN).
“All actuations and commentaries thereafter took off from the presentation with annotation by TV-radio personality Ted Failon of an aerial footage of my said property. He described said property as luxurious with several buildings and my house as a mansion, a villa,” he said.
“As such, pati na po ang mga ibang mga sikat na personality, tulad nila Mr. Noli De Castro, Mr. Alvin Elchico, Mr. Vic Lima, Ms. Karen Davila, Mr. Anthony Taberna at Gerry Baja ay panay ang batikos sa bahay ay mansion na rin,” he said.
After the show’s exposé, two separate charges of plunder against Purisima were lodged by groups including Coalition of Filipino Consumers’ Perfecto Tagalog and Volunteers Against Crime and Corruption’s Dante Jimenez.
Based on the complaints the groups filed, they accused Purisima of underdeclaring his properties, saying his house, with a swimming pool, could cost up to P15 million. Some experts interviewed by the media even said that the “mansion” was estimated to cost P50 million.
PNP Director General Alan Purisima’s property in San Leonardo, Nueva Ecija. PHOTO from PNP Public Information Office
But Purisima clarified that the market value of his San Leonardo house was only worth between P3 to P4 million. He said his property is an “ordinary house.”
The PNP chief also lamented that the negative publicity on him has influenced the perceptions of the Senators who grilled him during the Senate committee hearing last Tuesday.
“Tuloy, pati ang mga kagalang galang na mga Senador sa hearing namin ang buong paniwala ay mansion ang aking bahay sa Nueve Ecija,” he said.
Aerial shot
In the briefing, Purisima showed pictures of his house and lot, which he said he acquired in 1990.
While showing the photos, Purisima said the aerial shot of his house shown by Failon Ngayon was a “misrepresentation” of his property.
“Ang masama po sa aerial shot, mga kaibigan, ay hindi niyo makikita ang totoong nasa ibaba. Iyan po ang isa pang pagkakamali ng nagpresenta ng property ko,” he explained.
Under those roofs seen in the aerial view of his house, Purisima said these include a garage, a guest house and an old gazebo made of nipa. He said the assessor’s office of Nueva Ecija estimated the gazebo worth P17,890 only while the garage was worth P52,630.
The guest house, which he said was sometimes used as guard house, was assessed to be at P510,420.
PNP Director General Alan Purisima’s property in San Leonardo, Nueva Ecija. PHOTO from PNP Public Information Office
Contrary to claims that he has an olympic-size swimming pool, he clarified that it is measured 7.5 meters by 15 meters only.
“This is not even 10 percent of the size of an Olympic swimming pool which is at 50 meters by 215 meters,” he said.
While Failon’s television report said Purisima’s house was secured with high walls, he disproved this and flashed a pictures of low white fences and gates surrounding the property.
“Diyan pa lang po, makikita na malayong malayo maging mansion o villa ang aking bahay.”
Based on the tax declaration on real property in Nueva Ecija, Purisima said the office assessed his property and deemed its market value as P818,269.
But through the years, the value appreciated to P2,337,990, Purisima said.
“Friends and guests, this is the truth behind my house in San Leonardo. It is not a mansion. It is an ordinary house that has been improved over the years,” he added.
INQUIRER Website
http://newsinfo.inquirer.net/642022/palace-stands-by-purisima-says-response-to-wealth-issue-truthful
OTHER HUMAN RIGHTS PROMOTIONS WEBSITES
PROTECTION AND PROMOTION OF HUMAN RIGHTS
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
------------------------------------------------------------
-----------------------------
------------------------------------------------------------
-----------------------------
